Cold War (2-3), Ahh hell, here we go again! Options

[Aro]

Forgiven?

In the spirit of X-Mas approaching... A Present from me, to you!
My First snow map, and my first map with a day and night loop. That'll make Mr. Ixith happy.


Mini Map!




A Small town, during the night.




Random Land, sun slowly rising.




Finaly, it's morning!

[Ixith]

and so judgement day for this map has arrived...will it make it out well or will it be brought down...keep reading to find out! Laughing

anyways its review time:
Detail (since you were so mad I left it out on the last map): 9/10 Detail was good but something mostly in another category but relates to this one in a way brought it away from a 10.

Layout: 6/10 This being that category mentioned above. Its just too simple of a layout IMO. Cliffs are there but just seemed randomly spread out and don't really even create the pathways to use. Also I think you should have connected all the dirt roads so that they make a nice big system of roads.
oh and there were 2 cliff errors. See below pic.

Triggers: 8.5/10 nice to see the day/night loop. Smile Though I think more could have been done with moving vehicles which could have been more possible with the above mentioning of what you could have done with the dirt roads.

Lighting: 8/10 It was nice. Maybe a little bland though. The day/night loop added nice contrast from day and night. Although be careful of your alpha light posts during the day. In one area 2 or 3 of them were too close together and made for a blinding light area.

Game play: 7/10 meh it was ok but nothing stood out. Bases being openish due to the layout and not enough strategy for my liking kept this score from being higher.

Overall: 7.7 Its a nice little 3 player snow map that could just use a little more in just about every category. No spotlight vote from me on this one though unless it gets revamped.

oh and as for this comment that you made over at PPM (which I'm too lazy to respond to over there and plus I'm already logged in over here)

It's wierd the way you gave Gameplay a 5 and Ixith gave it a 7...

Thats because I don't judge gameplay as hard as I should. plus i was also being kind that it was your first snow map

and yea I agree with Crashy on that overlay buildings needs to go if you don't have a reason for it (at least as of now) instead of the real one. My only guess is cause the other ones didn't appear when you first started making it and you didn't go back to change it into a real building. (well my finalsun does that to me sometimes when making a snow map. Like I'll start it and certain buildings don't show on the list so I have to reload that map for them to show. )